I’ve been testing standing desks in my home office for almost 5 years. Most of the desks I review cost more than $800. Some of them cost as much as $2,000. But predictably, a question kept bugging me – what’s it like to live with a cheap $200 desk instead?
I didn’t have to look far to find one.
Above: The $199 Chatham from Officeworks even has 24 five-star reviews. What can go wrong?
Harvey Norman sells the Oikiture range of single-motor standing desks that start at $214.
Amazon has cheap desks that cost even less. Fezibo and Poriya brands start at $179 (how do they come up with these names?)
And because I’m a standing desk nerd, I drove there this morning to buy one – so you don’t have to.
It has the same or similar specs to every other cheap standing desk under $250:
- Single motor, check.
- 120 x 60 cm particleboard desktop, check.
- 50 kg weight capacity, check.
I discovered the problems below while testing the Chatham, but I’m reasonably confident that they’ll apply to any single-motor standing desk under $250.
Above: Will the cheap desk impress me? Let the testing begin.
Problem 1: The Gear.
It didn’t take long to find the Chatham’s Achilles’ heel. I stripped the motor to learn about the quality of its parts.
The image below shows the desk’s motor and gear assembly. The motor, which I’m holding in my hand, rotates the pink gear via a worm drive.
This pink gear, in turn, rotates the shaft that elevates the desk.
Here are the parts next to my case of AirPods for scale. I took this photo because I wanted you to realise how tiny these parts are.
This plastic gear is single-handedly responsible for raising and lowering both sides of the desk.
Above: The plastic gear explains the 50kg weight limit.
I wouldn’t call it “flimsy” right out of the gate, but I have strong doubts about its ability to endure typical standing desk loads for several years.
A metal gear would have been far more reassuring.
Problem 2: The Motor.
The desk is very slow. Officeworks doesn’t publish an official figure, but I’ve seen enough standing desks to know it’s in the 10-15mm/sec range.
I don’t usually mind if the desk travels at a modest pace (in fact, I’ve criticised standing desk brands for duping consumers with excessive emphasis on desk speed).
But in my books anything lower than 25mm/sec starts to feel frustrating. For context, most modern premium standing desks travel at 30-50mm/sec.
Above: The motor is small but surprisingly mighty.
The good news is that the motor copes well with heavy loads. The desk doesn’t get even slower when fully loaded.
I put 25kg of weight on it, fully expecting the desk’s speed to reduce to a stall, but it remained unchanged.
Problem 3: The Joints.
Expensive standing desk have joints that nest the leg inside the frame, which increases the desk’s stability.
Above: Thin sheetmetal and small screws hold crossbeams and legs together.
Cheap desks like the Chatham simply screws crossbars and leg columns together, with some overlap to help one part grip another.
This is an inferior design, but one that requires far less metal and a simpler fabrication process.
Problem 4: The Feet.
First of all, the feet on a cheap desk are much thinner, which means they’re more likely to flex, increasing back-to-front wobble.
Second, I was surprised to find that the Chatham’s feet were slightly turned up at each end, which further exacerbated the wobble. By a lot.
The desk effectively rocks back and forth on these feet – like a rocking chair.
Above: The desk’s heel and toe are turned upwards. Why?
I’d like to emphasise that this could be a Chatham-specific issue, so I won’t make a blanked judgement that all cheap standing desks suffer from it.
Problem 5: Cable Management.
Or, more precisely, the lack of it.
Don’t expect it when buying a cheap standing desk. You may be lucky enough to get a basic cable management kit that consists of a few hooks, but that’s it. No cable trays, no power boards, no internal power channels.
Above: Don’t expect a cable management tray for $199
You get a cross-bar, two legs and a desktop. This might seem like a trivial detail – and it is – but only if you don’t have much equipment.
If you have two devices (e.g., laptop and phone), the lack of cable management systems is a non-issue.
But it becomes one as soon as you start adding external monitors, additional computers or hard drives. The cable mess increases exponentially and your desk starts to look like powerlines in Thailand.
Expert Tip.
Buy a cable management tray from a premium standing desk brand, or on Amazon. You can pick one up for about $50. It doesn’t seem like much until you consider that it’s 1/4 of the desk’s total price.
Cheap vs Expensive Standing Desks: My Verdict.
A cheap $199 single-motor standing desk is great.
But only for kids, uni students or anyone else who is on a strict budget and is prepared to accept its poor stability and questionable longevity.
I definitely wouldn’t use one for propping up my expensive Apple monitor and a pair of FX30 cameras.
The back-to-front stability is atrocious, and I don’t want to worry about killing $10,000 worth of gear because I saved a thousand bucks on a standing desk.
Steven